Re: [Amel Yacht Owners] Steering Failure on 1992 SM72 "Aloha"
Stephen Davis
Thanks for going to all the hassle to get this info to me. I just got an answer from Maude this morning, they have the cables, and I asked her to ship them ASAP. In case you ever decide to change your cables, they are 335 euros plus shipping. After my experience, if you ever start to hear any noise or experience friction in the steering, I'd replace the racks, pinion, and cables all together. After having taken ours apart twice, and still one to go, it is not hard once you have solved a few mysteries. If you guys ever decide on a Hawaii vacation while we are still here, you would be welcome to stay on our boat which we keep in a very nice resort marina on West Oahu. Liz and I stay at at my parents home most of the week, and a couple of nights a week on the boat to maintain our sanity. Both my parents are in there 90's, and are requiring about as much maintenance as our old boats do. We hope to be on our way to French Polynesia in March 2019, but will have to see how things go with my folks. Steve
On Tue, Jul 17, 2018 at 12:41 PM Patrick Mcaneny sailw32@... [amelyachtowners] <amelyachtowners@...> wrote:
|
|
Re: [Amel Yacht Owners] Re: Steering Failure on 1992 SM72 "Aloha"
I posted my last before I read Bill Kinney quoting the Linear Drive's thrust as 480 kg. Raymarine shows both the linear drive and rotary drive handling a 20000 kg boat and they both have about the same power consumption, that is, essentially the same motors.
The difference seems that the linear drive has the mechanical advantage built in by way of its rotary-to-linear mechanism whereas the rotary unit has that mechanical advantage supplied externally by the rack and pinion and the sizing of the chain sprockets. And, as Bill notes, with normally small turns of the rudder, overcoming the back force of turning the wheel isn't a problem, and may not be a lot as compared with the 480 kg of thrust available. Interesting footnote to the Raymarine spec is that with the linear unit one must be able to back drive the steering system from the rudder. Sounds like a fun project, Herb, to add a linear drive to your Santorin, and I should think it will work just fine. Cheers, Craig ---In amelyachtowners@..., <sangaris@...> wrote : Excellent question, Herbert, and one I've wondered about, too. My wheel goes about 3 turns from stop to stop. That's 3 X 360° = 1080°. My rudder moves about 30° each way or 60° stop to stop. That's an 18:1 mechanical advantage, which is why Herb has to push so hard on the rudder to spin the wheel and move the rudder. (to say nothing of wheel diameter, rudder center of effort and friction) Granted the linear drive has a lever arm at the quadrant giving some mechanical advantage, but it seems it still must take much more force than the rotary drive. Interesting discussion. Cheers, Craig Herbert, There is no need to disconnect the cables when using the linear drive. The cables and wheel actually move quite freely, the force you need to move the rudder while on the hard manually is mostly just the inertia of the mass of the rudder. The inertia of the steering wheel adds some, but is not large. The linear drive generates 480 kg of force, and has no trouble turning the rudder even under very heavy loads. The cables and rack will see much reduced load and will wear LESS using the linear drive than they will using the chain drive. Most of the time, if the boat is trimmed well, the autopilot movements of the rudder should be very small. Bill Kinney SM160, Harmonie Annapolis, MD, USA ---In amelyachtowners@..., <herbert@...> wrote : Hi Bill, I think I could not express myself very clear, try to say it again, sorry for my English: when the rudder is moved by the rotary drive (or by the steering wheel) it moves very smooth, you can turn it with the "little finger". If I try to move the rudder (on the hard) by pushing or pulling it I need quite a lot of power until it moves (and of course the steering wheel turns also). So I thought, that the system is designed in a way that it runs very smooth when the power transmission goes from wheel to rudder but not the other way round (eg like a worm gear...). If the linear drive turns the rudder by moving the quadrant I thought that there might be a lot of friction until the steering wheel gets turned by the ultraflex cables. Is it true that the linear drive also turns the steering wheel when working - I assume yes? This is not a question how the Autopilot works but how the Amel Steering works thx, herbert
|
|
Re: [Amel Yacht Owners] Re: Attention Olivier Beaute
amel46met
Thanks Mark
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Aphrodite maramu 125
Tom Deasy
On Jul 17, 2018, at 2:12 PM, mfmcgovern@... [amelyachtowners] <amelyachtowners@...> wrote:
|
|
Re: [Amel Yacht Owners] Re: Steering Failure on 1992 SM72 "Aloha"
Excellent question, Herbert, and one I've wondered about, too.
My wheel goes about 3 turns from stop to stop. That's 3 X 360° = 1080°. My rudder moves about 30° each way or 60° stop to stop. That's an 18:1 mechanical advantage, which is why Herb has to push so hard on the rudder to spin the wheel and move the rudder. (to say nothing of wheel diameter, rudder center of effort and friction) Granted the linear drive has a lever arm at the quadrant giving some mechanical advantage, but it seems it still must take much more force than the rotary drive. Interesting discussion. Cheers, Craig ---In amelyachtowners@..., <herbert@...> wrote : Hi Bill, I think I could not express myself very clear, try to say it again, sorry for my English: when the rudder is moved by the rotary drive (or by the steering wheel) it moves very smooth, you can turn it with the "little finger". If I try to move the rudder (on the hard) by pushing or pulling it I need quite a lot of power until it moves (and of course the steering wheel turns also). So I thought, that the system is designed in a way that it runs very smooth when the power transmission goes from wheel to rudder but not the other way round (eg like a worm gear...). If the linear drive turns the rudder by moving the quadrant I thought that there might be a lot of friction until the steering wheel gets turned by the ultraflex cables. Is it true that the linear drive also turns the steering wheel when working - I assume yes? This is not a question how the Autopilot works but how the Amel Steering works thx, herbert
|
|
Re: [Amel Yacht Owners] Steering Failure on 1992 SM72 "Aloha"
Patrick McAneny
Steve, I just made a template the best I could with all the bolts , it is pretty good and with the additional pics I took ,it should help. I will mail it off to you and email the pics when my wife gets home. Its been six years since the install , I remember it was a little tricky establishing where to position the motors mount. I gave a measurement in one of the pics as a starting point. The steering cables stay in the same hole in the quadrant ,just drill a hole in the extension arm directly above it . You can see that I fiber glassed in a 11/2" wood block to pack out the bulkhead as well as aft of the bulkhead to also add strength . If the arm is positioned so that the rudder is on center line and the linear drive is 1/2 way extended than I would think that should be where the motor is mounted . You need to make sure you have complete travel of course. I can't remember how I determined the motor mount position, it took a little experimenting. If the rudder is hard to starboard and the drive fully extended and you marked the mount position, and then moved the rudder hard to port with the L/D fully retracted and marked that , the correct position would be half way between the marks, I would think. Just play with it before drilling the holes for the mounting. Also sending pic of the hatch I installed shortly after buying the boat , best thing I ever did . Great amount of air ,makes a hot aft cabin cool. They should have come with a hatch and do now.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Let me know if you have any questions.
Good Luck,
Pat
SM Shenanigans
Sassafras River, Md.
-----Original Message----- From: Patrick Mcaneny sailw32@... [amelyachtowners] To: amelyachtowners Sent: Mon, Jul 16, 2018 8:25 pm Subject: Re: [Amel Yacht Owners] Steering Failure on 1992 SM72 "Aloha" Steve, I am glad you have the same layout. No worries about the mailing ,my treat. We'll get everything on the way to you asap.
Thanks,
Pat
SM Shenanigans
-----Original Message-----
From: Stephen Davis flyboyscd@... [amelyachtowners] <amelyachtowners@...> To: amelyachtowners <amelyachtowners@...> Sent: Mon, Jul 16, 2018 7:34 pm Subject: Re: [Amel Yacht Owners] Steering Failure on 1992 SM72 "Aloha" Thanks Pat...it is greatly appreciated. We have modified our aft stateroom a bit by removing the fiberglass liners on both sides, building the berth on the port side out to King size at the head and queen at the foot, and adding new cabinetry on the stbd side. With that said, the area under the port berth where the drive will go, is not changed in any way that will cause an issue.
I’ll give you my Hawaii address below, and please let me know if I can send you a check or do a pay pal to reimburse you for mailing cost..
Aloha,
Steve
Steve Davis
95-464 Kaelo Place
Mililani, Hawaii 96789
Cell: 510-908-1835
Steve Davis
S/V Aloha
On Jul 16, 2018, at 12:33 PM, Patrick Mcaneny sailw32@... [amelyachtowners] <amelyachtowners@...> wrote:
|
|
Re: [Amel Yacht Owners] Re: Steering Failure on 1992 SM72 "Aloha"
greatketch@...
Herbert,
There is no need to disconnect the cables when using the linear drive. The cables and wheel actually move quite freely, the force you need to move the rudder while on the hard manually is mostly just the inertia of the mass of the rudder. The inertia of the steering wheel adds some, but is not large. The linear drive generates 480 kg of force, and has no trouble turning the rudder even under very heavy loads. The cables and rack will see much reduced load and will wear LESS using the linear drive than they will using the chain drive. Most of the time, if the boat is trimmed well, the autopilot movements of the rudder should be very small. Bill Kinney SM160, Harmonie Annapolis, MD, USA
|
|
Re: [Amel Yacht Owners] Re: Steering Failure on 1992 SM72 "Aloha"
Patrick McAneny
Herbert, Yes the linear drive moves all the components connected to the steering system. I am not an engineer , but I suspect it all comes down to leverage imposed from the helm is greater than what you impose from the rudder. As to wear ,it would be the same ,as when employing the rotary ,all the same parts are moving. I suppose if you took the chain off the rotary drive ,you could save that from moving , but the wear is minimum and would not be a good idea.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Pat
SM#123
-----Original Message----- From: herbert@... [amelyachtowners] To: amelyachtowners Sent: Tue, Jul 17, 2018 10:51 am Subject: Re: [Amel Yacht Owners] Re: Steering Failure on 1992 SM72 "Aloha" Hi Bill, I think I could not express myself very clear, try to say it again, sorry for my English:
when the rudder is moved by the rotary drive (or by the steering wheel) it moves very smooth, you can turn it with the "little finger". If I try to move the rudder (on the hard) by pushing or pulling it I need quite a lot of power until it moves (and of course the steering wheel turns also). So I thought, that the system is designed in a way that it runs very smooth when the power transmission goes from wheel to rudder but not the other way round (eg like a worm gear...).
If the linear drive turns the rudder by moving the quadrant I thought that there might be a lot of friction until the steering wheel gets turned by the ultraflex cables. Is it true that the linear drive also turns the steering wheel when working - I assume yes?
This is not a question ho
w the Autopilot works but how the Amel Steering works
thx, herbert
|
|
Re: [Amel Yacht Owners] Re: Steering Failure on 1992 SM72 "Aloha"
Herbert Lackner
Hi Bill, I think I could not express myself very clear, try to say it again, sorry for my English: when the rudder is moved by the rotary drive (or by the steering wheel) it moves very smooth, you can turn it with the "little finger". If I try to move the rudder (on the hard) by pushing or pulling it I need quite a lot of power until it moves (and of course the steering wheel turns also). So I thought, that the system is designed in a way that it runs very smooth when the power transmission goes from wheel to rudder but not the other way round (eg like a worm gear...). If the linear drive turns the rudder by moving the quadrant I thought that there might be a lot of friction until the steering wheel gets turned by the ultraflex cables. Is it true that the linear drive also turns the steering wheel when working - I assume yes? This is not a question how the Autopilot works but how the Amel Steering works thx, herbert
|
|
Re: [Amel Yacht Owners] Re: Steering Failure on 1992 SM72 "Aloha"
It is very possible that you will need to reverse polarity if the physical alignment is reversed. Think about it and you'll understand that the course computer controlls right and left rudder by reversing polarity. Best, CW Bill Rouse Admiral, Texas Navy Commander Emeritus Amel School www.amelschool.com 720 Winnie St Galveston Island, TX 77550 +1(832) 380-4970
|
|
Re: [Amel Yacht Owners] Re: Steering Failure on 1992 SM72 "Aloha"
Herbert Lackner
maybe a stupid question from a SN owner: when adding a linear drive -- the rotary steering system stays exactly the same, no changes, is that right? No need to disconnect the cables when switching to the linear drive? When I try to move the rudder by hand (on the hard, when applying antifouling...) this is not easy and needs some power, when I turn the wheel it is very easy, so I thought there might be also some wear on the steering system when the rudder is moved by the linear drive and the cables and chain and wheel will turn also... that was the reason for me not to plan a linear drive installation but to carry second course computer and rotary drive engine as spares... thx, herbert, KALI MERA, SN 120, Shelter Bay
|
|
Re: Attention Olivier Beaute
mfmcgovern@...
olivierbeaute at gmail dot com and atlanticyachtsurvey at yahoo dot com
Mark McGovern SM 440 Cara Deale' MD USA
|
|
Re: Storage in the galley Super Maramu 2000
Thanks Gary and John for your very detailed responses to my dilemma. Michael and I spent the afternoon rearranging some of the lockers, cupboards and the bilges and now feel reasonably happy with the outcome. I realize that we will probably change things again as we spend more time aboard and figure out what needs to be accessed readily. Looking forward to this new chaper in our lives and the experiences that follow. Regards, Elaine and Michael SV Nebo No. 251 Sent from my Samsung Galaxy smartphone.
|
|
Re: [Amel Yacht Owners] Storage in the galley Super Maramu 2000
Hi Mark, We are currently in Hobart, Tasmania which is a beautiful part of the world. Will be there for winter as we sort out Nebo. Our first project was to get the diesel heater working and I am very happy to report that its now toasty warm aboard after replacing the glow plug. Regards, Elaine and Michael SV Nebo No. 251 Sent from my Samsung Galaxy smartphone.
|
|
Attention Olivier Beaute
amel46met
Olivier could you send me your email address.
To onboardaphrodite at hot mail.com
|
|
New file uploaded to amelyachtowners
amelyachtowners@...
Hello,
This email message is a notification to let you know that a file has been uploaded to the Files area of the amelyachtowners group. File : /Amel Drawings/JibFurler_SM29.pdf Uploaded by : sailor63109 <sailor63109@yahoo.com> Description : Amel Dwg of the jib furler You can access this file at the URL: https://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/amelyachtowners/files/Amel%20Drawings/JibFurler_SM29.pdf To learn more about file sharing for your group, please visit: https://help.yahoo.com/kb/index?page=content&y=PROD_GRPS&locale=en_US&id=SLN15398 Regards, sailor63109 <sailor63109@yahoo.com>
|
|
Re: Genoa electric furling gears
Duane Siegfri
Kostas,
Thanks for posting the plans, I'll find a place to put them in the "Files" section. Best regards, Duane
|
|
Re: [Amel Yacht Owners] Steering Failure on 1992 SM72 "Aloha"
Patrick McAneny
Steve, I am glad you have the same layout. No worries about the mailing ,my treat. We'll get everything on the way to you asap.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Thanks,
Pat
SM Shenanigans
-----Original Message----- From: Stephen Davis flyboyscd@... [amelyachtowners] To: amelyachtowners Sent: Mon, Jul 16, 2018 7:34 pm Subject: Re: [Amel Yacht Owners] Steering Failure on 1992 SM72 "Aloha" Thanks Pat...it is greatly appreciated. We have modified our aft stateroom a bit by removing the fiberglass liners on both sides, building the berth on the port side out to King size at the head and queen at the foot, and adding new cabinetry on the stbd side. With that said, the area under the port berth where the drive will go, is not changed in any way that will cause an issue.
I’ll give you my Hawaii address below, and please let me know if I can send you a check or do a pay pal to reimburse you for mailing cost.
Aloha,
Steve
Steve Davis
95-464 Kaelo Place
Mililani, Hawaii 96789
Cell: 510-908-1835
Steve Davis
S/V Aloha
On Jul 16, 2018, at 12:33 PM, Patrick Mcaneny sailw32@... [amelyachtowners] <amelyachtowners@...> wrote:
|
|
Re: [Amel Yacht Owners] Steering Failure on 1992 SM72 "Aloha"
Stephen Davis
Thanks Pat...it is greatly appreciated. We have modified our aft stateroom a bit by removing the fiberglass liners on both sides, building the berth on the port side out to King size at the head and queen at the foot, and adding new cabinetry on the stbd side. With that said, the area under the port berth where the drive will go, is not changed in any way that will cause an issue.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
I’ll give you my Hawaii address below, and please let me know if I can send you a check or do a pay pal to reimburse you for mailing cost. Aloha, Steve Steve Davis 95-464 Kaelo Place Mililani, Hawaii 96789 Cell: 510-908-1835 Steve Davis S/V Aloha
On Jul 16, 2018, at 12:33 PM, Patrick Mcaneny sailw32@... [amelyachtowners] <amelyachtowners@...> wrote:
|
|
Re: [Amel Yacht Owners] Steering Failure on 1992 SM72 "Aloha"
Patrick McAneny
Steve, It is a pretty straight forward solution ,uses no usable space and does not require cutting out any structural components . Remember you need a 24 v linear drive with the long arm. You will also want to buy an A/B switch , in order to switch back and forth between the rotary and linear drive. I will send photo of that as well.I will very soon take many more photos and measurements for you . Do you have the same layout as I do, with the berth to port ? I will try to make a template of the extension arm . Would you have an address , I could mail it to you? By the way, congratulations on making a long passage and dealing well through your steering issue.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Pat
SM Shenanigans
-----Original Message-----
From: Stephen Davis flyboyscd@... [amelyachtowners] To: amelyachtowners Sent: Mon, Jul 16, 2018 4:50 pm Subject: Re: [Amel Yacht Owners] Steering Failure on 1992 SM72 "Aloha" Patrick, I have looked at the photo section, and your technique, seems the most simple of the 2 different methods I’ve seen this done with an older SM. We are definitely going to do the job with your method, but not until we get the steering fixed. Any dimensions or template for the quadrant extension would save me a lot of time and energy trying to re-invent the wheel. Since I have the steering apart now, I may start to do some of the legwork in the near future. Whenever you have to time, I’d greatly appreciate it if you can send me what you have.
Thanks,
Steve Davis
S/V Aloha
On Jul 16, 2018, at 9:39 AM, Patrick Mcaneny sailw32@... [amelyachtowners] <amelyachtowners@...> wrote:
|
|
Re: [Amel Yacht Owners] Storage in the galley Super Maramu 2000
Hi Mark, We are currently in Hobart, Tasmania which is a beautiful part of the world and will be staying here for winter while we sort Nebo out. First project was to get the diesel heater going which I am very happy to report works well after replacing the glow plug. Regards, Elaine and Michael SV Nebo No. 251 Sent from my Samsung Galaxy smartphone.
-------- Original message --------
From: "'Mark Erdos' mcerdos@... [amelyachtowners]" <amelyachtowners@...> Date:16/07/2018 21:01 (GMT+10:00) To: amelyachtowners@... Cc: Subject: RE: [Amel Yacht Owners] Storage in the galley Super Maramu 2000
Hi Elaine,
Where are you located?
With best regards,
Mark
Skipper Sailing Vessel - Cream Puff - SM2K - #275 Currently cruising - Curacao
From:
amelyachtowners@... [mailto:amelyachtowners@...]
Hi everyone, I am a new member and a new owner of our first yacht, Amel SM hull no. 251.
Moved onboard a few weeks ago and still unpacking and finding places for our belongings. I am a keen cook and have quite a large pantry of what I consider essentials and having trouble organising the cupboards in the galley. Would appreciate any input from the owners out there as to how they have gone about doing it. The deep, top opening locker in the galley is proving to be the most difficult. Also has anyone removed the bottle racks to gain extra storage. Thanks in advance. Elaine
Sent from my Samsung Galaxy smartphone.
|
|